Indiana Court of Appeals March 5, 1998, 45A03-9705-CV-162 (Common Council of Hammond v. Matonovich)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-03-1998

OPINION

STATON, Judge.

The Common Council of the City of Hammond (“Common Council”) and numerous Hammond taxpayers (“Taxpayers”), collectively referred to hereinafter as the “Appellants,” appeal from the trial court’s dismissal of their suit against John Matonovieh, the Assessor of North Township in Lake County. The Appellants raise several issues, one of which is dispositive. We restate it as: whether the Lake Superior Court erred by dismissing Appellants’ lawsuit due to Appellants’ failure to exhaust their administrative remedies.

We affirm.

*1328

The facts as alleged in the complaint are that in April 1996, Matonovich sent property-reassessment notices to the Taxpayers. The notices purported to serve as a “general revaluation” of each taxpayer’s property. In June and again in August of 1996, Matono-vich mailed additional reassessment notices to the Taxpayers. Again, the reason given for the reassessments was a “general revaluation.” Thus, each taxpayer’s property was reassessed three times between April and August of 1996, resulting in up to three different assessed values being placed on a single parcel of property within a five-month period.

In December 1996, the Taxpayers, joined by the Common Council, filed this lawsuit in the Lake Superior Court requesting,

inter alia,

that the court vacate all three property reassessments. The Appellants asserted in their complaint that Matonovich lacked statutory authority to issue any of the reassessment notices. In response Matonovich filed an Ind. Trial Rule 12(B)(1) motion to dismiss, contending

inter alia,

that the trial court lacked subject matter jurisdiction due to the Appellants’ failure to exhaust their administrative remedies. The trial court granted Matonovich’s motion; this appeal ensued.

When a trial court is confronted with a T.R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.