California Court of Appeal December 30, 1998, G016950, G019250, G022132 (TINY B., INC. v. City of Newport Beach)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1998

Opinion

BEDSWORTH, J.

The sine qua non of a life in the law is a willingness to devote a great deal of thought to issues which seldom concern nonlawyers. In this case, for example, we discuss appropriate ways in which to distinguish a theater from a restaurant—something with which the general public

*8

seems to have absolutely no difficulty, but which regularly defies the best efforts of courts and counsel.

This is a dispute over the extent to which the City of Newport Beach may constitutionally regulate the operation of the Mermaid, an adult entertainment establishment owned and operated by Tily B., Inc., of which An and Olivia Nguyen are the sole shareholders (Mermaid).

The Mermaid appeals first from a judgment denying its petitions for writs of mandate to compel the city to issue use and entertainment permits. The city appeals from a judgment holding unconstitutional an ordinance prohibiting nude dancing (the “pasties and G-string” ordinance) and granting a writ of mandate directing it to repeal the ordinance. The Mermaid reconfigured its club to meet city requirements and obtained the needed permits, later revoked by the city, and now it also appeals from a judgment that denied its petition for a writ of mandate ordering the city to set aside the revocation/ nonrenewal of its permits, granted summary judgment for the city on the Mermaid’s claims for deprivation of civil rights under 42 United States Code section 1983, and permanently enjoined the Mermaid from operating without required city permits.

The Mermaid argues that city ordinances violated its rights under the United States and California Constitutions, and that there were triable issues of fact on its federal civil rights claims precluding summary judgment. The city, in turn, argues that its pasties and G-string ordinance is constitutional.

We hold the city did not violate the Mermaid’s constitutional rights in denying the initial permit applications and affirm the decision in No. G016950.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.