California Court of Appeal November 16, 1998, B116305 (Aguirre-Alvarez v. Regents of University of California)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1998

Opinion

BOREN, P. J.

Does a hospital treating a patient in constructive police custody who dies at the hospital from gunshot wounds inflicted by police owe a duty to the decedent’s relatives to locate and notify them? We conclude that the hospital does not owe such a duty.

Facts

Appellants Manuel Aguirre and Rosa Alvarez are the parents of the deceased, 19-year-old Alfonso Aguirre-Alvarez (decedent). Appellant Apolonio Aguirre-Alvarez (Aguirre-Alvarez) is decedent’s brother and the appointed personal representative of his brother’s estate. Paramedics transported decedent on May 7, 1992, to University of California Los Angeles Medical Center (UCLA), where he was admitted for emergency trauma care. Decedent had suffered six gunshot wounds to his chest, abdomen, and upper left extremity.

1

The gunshots injured several internal organs, decedent’s spinal column, and his blood vessels. One of the injuries was to his colon, probably resulting in fecal matter infecting the abdominal cavity.

Initially, UCLA listed decedent as “John Doe.” Subsequently, in accordance with hospital policy regarding patients with gunshot wounds or who have been involved in criminal activity, the hospital listed decedent on its charts and records under the alias “Frederick Inman.”

UCLA surgeons performed a number of exploratory and remedial procedures. Physicians treated decedent aggressively with antibiotics. It was undisputed that the first three surgeries were performed consistent with the standard of care and did not cause decedent’s death. Because of the condition of decedent’s wounds, his chest cavity could not be completely closed,

*1061

air leaks developed,

2

and defendants found it impossible to “plug all the holes between the chest and belly.” On May 13,1992, the treating physicians diagnosed intra-abdominal peritonitis and necrotizing fascitis of his anterior abdominal wall. Decedent was treated for these severe infections, but further complications developed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.