District Court, D. Utah August 10, 1998, 2:95 CV 1068 K (Feichko v. Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-08-1998

ORDER

KIMBALL, District Judge.

This matter is before the Court on Plaintiff Frank Feichko, Jr.’s

Motion for Partial Summary Judgment,

determining that Defendant Denver & Rio Grande Western Railroad (“Denver & Rio Grande”) is negligent as a matter of law and that Plaintiff was not contributorily negligent as a matter of law, and Denver & Rio Grande’s Cross

Motion for Complete Summary Judgment.

Oral argument was held on August 7, 1998, where Denver & Rio Grande’s recently-filed

Motion for an Order Prohibiting Plaintiff from Raising a New Claim or Alternatively Granting a Continuance

was also considered. This Order sets forth the Court’s ruling on these three motions, which were taken under advisement after oral argument.

Background

Plaintiff is an experienced railroad engineer and was employed as such by Denver & Rio Grande. On January 11,1993, Plaintiffs day off, Plaintiff was involved in an accident that occurred on Denver & Rio Grande’s yard in Helper, Utah.

Plaintiff had gone to the yard on that day to search for his missing checkbook. Before entering the yard, Plaintiff first sought and obtained permission from his supervisor to look for the checkbook in the cabs of two parked locomotives. While he was in the cab of Locomotive 5390, a “consist” of four engines- operated by Jesse Needles, another Denver & Rio Grande engineer, crashed into it, knocking him to the floor and allegedly causing him to sustain serious injuries.

The exact cause of the . accident has never been established. Following the accident, the consist’s brakes were tested and found to be in working order. Needles and the brake operator, who was also on the consist, both testified that as they were slowing the consist, it suddenly sped up and slid, as a car would on black ice.

Plaintiff asserts that the only explanation for the accident is negligence on the part of Denver & Rio Grande and claims that Denver & Rio Grande is liable for Plaintiff’s injuries as a matter of law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.