Court of Special Appeals of Maryland January 29, 1998, 1167, Sept. Term, 1996 (Adams v. Owens-Illinois, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-1998

JAMES S. GETTY, Judge (retired),

Specially Assigned.

This is an appeal from jury verdicts in nine asbestos cases that were consolidated for trial in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. The trial judge (Pines, J.) also consolidated 159 additional asbestos cases involving eleven corporate defendants. The verdicts at trial, therefore, were binding as to negligence and product liability in all of the consolidated cases.

*399

The complexity of the cases is best illustrated by the length of the trial. The plaintiffs! cases consumed forty-two trial days, and the defendants’ presentation lasted nineteen days. The entire case, from jury selection until the verdicts were rendered, lasted approximately six months, beginning January 17, 1995, and ending July 26, 1995. The jury deliberated for fifteen and one-half hours over a three-day period.

The plaintiffs and their alleged asbestos-related diseases were:

1. Estate of George Best and surviving widow, Almetta Best, laryngeal cancer.

2. Thomas Birchett and Louise Birchett, lung cancer.

3. Estate of Abram Hedges and surviving widow, Marie Hedges, lung cancer.

4. Estate of Hody Ruffin, colon cancer.

5. Dominic and Dossie D’Amico, asbestosis.

6. Edwin Wild and the Estate of Mary Wild, asbestosis.

7. Claim of Edwin Wild, Estate of Mary Wild and Edwin Wild, surviving husband, mesothelioma — death by household exposure.

8. Estate of Phillip Parsons and Elsie Parsons, surviving widow, mesothelioma.

9. Estate of Charles Drebing and Mildred Drebing, surviving widow, mesothelioma.

The jury returned verdicts for the defendants in the first seven cases set forth above, and plaintiffs’ verdicts in cases numbered eight and nine. The damages awarded in the Parsons case included no damages for wrongful death, and $86,000 in the estate case. In Drebing, the jury allowed compensatory damages in the amount of $112,500 to Mildred Drebing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.