Supreme Court of New Jersey July 17, 1998 (Baxt v. Liloia)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-07-1998

PORITZ, C.J.

In this appeal, plaintiffs have asked the Court to recognize a new cause of action premised upon a breach of the Rules of Professional Conduct (“RPCs” or “Rules”) adopted by the Court for the governance of the legal profession. More specifically, plaintiffs urge us to permit this new claim to be brought against attorneys who represent an adversary of the claimant. A

majority of

the Appellate Division declined to sanction lawsuits “based solely on an allegation that the conduct of the[] defendants violated the Rules of Professional Conduct.” 284

N.J.Super.

221, 223, 664 A.2d 948 (1995)

(Baxt

II). The dissenting member would permit civil liability upon a violation of the Rules resulting in foreseeable injury to a third party.

Id.

at 224, 664 A.2d 948 (Dreier, P.J.A.D., dissenting). The issue is before the Court as of right pursuant to

Buie

2:2-l(a)(2).

See Manalapan Realty v. Township Committee,

140

N.J.

366, 377, 658 A.2d 1230 (1995). We agree with the majority of the panel below and affirm with modifications not relevant to this issue.

I

This case arose as a dispute over the propriety of litigation tactics used by defendants Gerald Liloia and Anthony Sylvester in an underlying foreclosure suit. Plaintiff Sherwood Baxt was a partner with Paul Hartman and Paul Baxt (“the debtors”) in The Grove Mercantile Center (“Grove”). Both Sherwood Baxt and plaintiff Saida Baxt were defendants in the foreclosure suit brought by the Summit Trust Company (“Summit”) alleging Grove’s default on a construction loan from Summit to Grove.

*194

Defendants Liloia and Sylvester are attorneys who represented Summit in the foreclosure litigation.

Grove obtained construction financing for a commercial real estate project in Jersey City from Summit in October 1988 by way of two mortgage loans, one for $8.8 million and the other for $300,000. The original documents provided for periodic advances to Grove and for repayment of the entire debt on November 1, 1989.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.