Texas Court of Appeals, 6th District (Texarkana) August 6, 1998, 06-97-00121-CV (Friday v. Spears)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-08-1998
OPINION
GRANT, Justice.
Angela Webb Friday appeals a judgment in favor of Pamela Sue Spears in Friday’s personal injury suit against Spears.
In a single point of error, Friday contends that the trial court erred by including a definition of “unavoidable accident” in the court’s charge to the jury. Friday argues that no evidence was presented at trial to justify the instruction.
This ease arises from an automobile collision that occurred on April 22, 1996. Evidence presented showed that Friday was driving in her vehicle immediately in front of Spears. The road was wet and slick from rain. A vehicle in front of Friday stopped suddenly to make a turn, which caused Friday to step on her brakes. Spears testified that she applied her brakes, hydroplaned, and hit Friday’s vehicle. The collision resulted in slight damage to Friday’s bumper and license plate. Friday also testified that she sustained injuries which caused her physical pain and suffering. X-rays taken immediately after the accident showed no injury. However, the emergency room physician told Friday that she had whiplash. Friday did not work for three weeks following the collision and was treated by a chiropractor for eight weeks for her injuries.
The trial court included in its charge a definition of “unavoidable accident,” to which Friday objected. The jury returned a verdict in favor of Spears. Judgment on the verdict was rendered on August 21, 1997. Friday filed a Motion for New Trial, which was denied.
The trial court’s jury charge is reviewed using an abuse of discretion standard of review.
1
A trial court has considerable discretion in submitting explanatory instructions and definitions.
2
If the charge resolves the controlling issues raised by the pleadings and any evidence in a feasible manner that does not confuse the jury, no error occurs.
3
Error in the jury charge is reversible only if it probably caused the rendition of an improper verdict.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit