Missouri Court of Appeals April 28, 1998, WD 54404 (State v. Spidle)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-04-1998

SPINDEN, Judge.

In his appeal of the circuit court’s judgment convicting him of statutory rape in the first degree, Lawrence Dale Spidle complains about the prosecutor’s questions and comments during

voir dire.

1

Spidle asserts that the circuit court erred in allowing the prosecutor to question the venire panel regarding what type of evidence they would require to convict, to comment on Spidle’s right to testify, and to define “proof beyond a reasonable doubt.” We affirm the circuit court’s judgment.

Spidle did not object to any of the state’s comments during

voir dire,

so he did not preserve the issues for our review. He asks us, however, to review the matter as plain error under Rule 30.20. The Supreme Court has defined plain error as error which, on its face, gives an appellate court substantial grounds for believing that manifest injustice has resulted from the error.

State v. Brown,

902 S.W.2d 278, 284 (Mo. banc),

cert. denied,

516 U.S.

1031, 116 S.Ct. 679, 133

L.Ed.2d 527 (1995).

*291

Spidle first complains about a group of questions which he asserts that the prosecutor intended to indoctrinate and to predispose the potential jurors to favoring the state’s case. He argues that he was prejudiced because the panel was forced to speculate on how they would react to the anticipated evidence and to commit to a guilty verdict. The prosecutor asked these questions:

Is there anyone here that disagrees with the law that does not allow the jury to consider whether the child consented to the intercourse? In other words, under the law, consent is not a defense? Does anyone disagree with that?

Does anyone here feel that a child deserves less protection under the law than an adult does?

Does anyone here feel that the burden of proof in this case should be higher because it involves the rape of a child as compared to some other sort of a crime?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.