District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania November 5, 1998, Civil Action 96-5216 (Whitmill v. City of Philadelphia)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-11-1998
MEMORANDUM AND ORDER
HART, United States Magistrate Judge.
In
this civil rights case, the court granted judgment as a matter of law in favor of the City of Philadelphia and the former Police Commissioner on the plaintiffs
Monell
claim. Thereafter, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the remaining defendants on the remainder of the claims. Presently before the court is plaintiffs “Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law or in the Alternative Motion for a New Trial.” In his motion, plaintiff makes several assertions of trial court error. Each will be addressed individually. However, much of Plaintiffs motion rests on his argument that Mr. Whitmill’s brief detention and 5 block transportation prior to his being identified by two eyewitnesses constituted an arrest as a matter of law. Therefore, the court will address that issue first.
On July 24, 1994, Coleman Whitmill was stopped by Police Officers William Suarez and Nicholas DiPasquale at 15th and Butler Streets because, according to the officers, Mr. Whitmill fit the description of one of the perpetrators of a robbery/kidnapping, and later shooting, that had occurred earlier in the day. The officers handcuffed Mr. Whit-mill and placed him in the back of their police van, waiting for one of the witnesses to arrive to identify Mr. Whitmill.
*243
While waiting for the witness, a news van parked near the police van and a cameraman exited the vehicle. In order to protect Mr. Whitmill’s privacy and in order to prevent any taint of the investigation, Officers Suarez and DiPasquale drove Mr. Whitmill five blocks to Temple Hospital for the identification procedure. There, Frederick Boyle, an off-duty Housing Authority Officer who had given chase to the get-away vehicle and been shot, and Mr. Joseph Roche, a witness to the Boyle shooting, were taken, individually, to the back of the police van in order to view Mr. Whitmill. Mr. Whitmill was never asked to face the witnesses, stand up, or exit the vehicle.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit