District Court, M.D. Georgia July 23, 1998, 5:96-cv-00304 (Davis Bros., Inc. v. Thornton Oil Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-07-1998
ORDER
OWENS, District Judge.
Davis Brothers, Inc. (“Davis Bros.”), filed suit against Thornton Oil Company (“Thornton”) and Conoco/Kayo Oil Company (“Cono-co”)
1
under several theories alleging it is entitled to monetary damages resulting from a gasoline leak that occurred
while the
defendants operated a gas station on property leased from Davis Bros.
2
Thornton filed a cross-claim against Conoco arguing it should
*1335
be indemnified by Conoco for all damages and costs, including attorney’s fees, associated with this litigation pursuant to one or both of two separate agreements.
3
The court held a hearing on several motions on January 12, 1998. Subsequent to the hearing, Davis Bros, and Conoco settled all claims between them, and Davis Bros, assigned its claim against Thornton to Conoco.
Currently before the court are Thornton’s motion for summary judgment on Davis Bros.’ claims against it, and cross motions for summary judgment filed by Thornton and Conoco against each other. In addition, Co-noco has filed a motion, opposed by Thornton, requesting that the court substitute it as plaintiff pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 25(c). Finally, Davis Bros, filed a motion to strike a portion of Thornton’s reply in support of Thornton’s motion for summary judgment. Having carefully considered the arguments- of counsel, the relevant case law and the record as a whole, the court issues the following order.
I. Undisputed Facts
The following facts are undisputed, but the legal conclusions to be taken from those facts are, of course, in dispute.
In 1975, Davis Bros, leased with an option to buy four contiguous properties located on and near Lee Street and Georgia Highway 42 in Forsyth, Georgia. On September 10, 1975, Thornton subleased one of the properties from Davis Bros., installed underground storage tanks (USTs), and began operating a service station on the property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit