United States Court of International Trade August 17, 1998, Slip. Op. 98-119. Court No. 95-02-00177 (Century Importers, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-08-1998

OPINION

RESTANI, Judge.

This action is before the court on crossmo-tions for summary judgment, pursuant to USCIT Rule 56. The court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1581(a) (1994), as plaintiff challenges denial of its protest of a Customs valuation decision with regard to beer imported from Canada.

FACTS

The merchandise at issue was imported via four entries made in 1993. At the time of entry normal duty rates had been replaced by a 50 percent duty. By virtue of a “Side Letter Agreement,” dated January 14, 1993, the exporter, Molson Brewing Company, agreed to reimburse Miller Brewing Company for the duty paid.

1

One of Miller’s subsidiaries, Century Importers, is the importer of record. Another subsidiary paid the original invoice price to Molson and after importation Molson reimbursed it for the duties paid. Thus, as of January 14, 1993, the sum total of the sales agreements resulted in a price (known as the “Transfer Price”) which was to be the same from Miller’s point of view, no matter what the duty rate. From Molson’s point of view, what it actually received in payment was going to change depending on the duty paid. This appears to be essentially a “duty paid” price transaction. The parties, however, did not label this a “duty paid” transaction, nor did the papers submitted at entry reflect anything other than a unitary invoice price.

Plaintiff asserts that, nonetheless, this was a “duty paid” transaction and that this was revealed to Customs when plaintiff presented the side agreement to Customs prior to liquidation of the entries, together with evidence of the monetary adjustments made between Molson and Miller after the duty was paid.

2

Defendant argues that it properly calculated transaction value for purposes of calculation of duties. Defendant states that there was only a transaction price, and it did not include duties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.