United States Court of International Trade March 24, 1998, Slip Op. 98-32. Court No. 89-09-00535 (NEC Home Electronics, Ltd. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-1998

OPINION

MUSGRAVE, Senior Judge.

In this action the Court considers defendant U.S. Department of Commerce’s (“DOC” or “Commerce”) Final Results of Redetermination Pursuant to Court Remand. Plaintiffs NEC Home Electronics, Ltd. and NEC Technologies, Inc. (“NEC”) challenge the Final Results and seek a further remand to recalculate an imposed dumping duty.

Background

This case concerns the calculation by Commerce of an antidumping duty in connection with NEC’s sales of televisions over a four year period. The subject merchandise was produced by NEC' Home Electronics, Ltd., (“NECHE”), and distributed by NECHE’s related sales companies in the home market (“NECSCs”) and in the U.S. market (“NECHE (USA)”) (collectively “NEC”). Commerce published the final results of its antidumping duty administrative review in 1989, and NEC challenged the DOC’s methodology and conclusions.

In calculating the foreign market value (“FMV”) of NEC’s merchandise for comparison with the U.S. price and determination of a dumping margin,

1

Commerce based FMV on sales by the NECSCs to their unrelated customers.

See Television Receivers, Monochrome and Color, from Japan; Final Results of Antidumping Duty Administrative Review and Determination Not To Revoke in Part,

54 Fed.Reg. 35,517 (1989). NEC challenged that decision on the grounds that its sales between NECHE and the NECSCs, while related parties, were at arm’s length, and therefore these transactions should be the basis for determining FMV. The DOC found that NEC had not provided data to support its assertion and rejected this argument

Id.

at 35,522.

*1453

Upon review, this Court affirmed the DOC’s conclusion.

NEC Home Electronics, Ltd. v. United States,

18 C.I.T. 336, 1994 WL 176914 (1994). The Court found that the DOC could not examine NEC’s sales to related parties to determine whether they were at arm’s length because that information had been submitted in an untimely fashion.

Id.

at 339-40.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.