Oregon Supreme Court October 7, 1998, CC 98C-17232; CA A103357; SC S45677 (Leo v. Keisling)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-10-1998
*559
LEESON, J.
In this certified appeal, the parties ask us to decide the following question:
“Is it unconstitutional for the Secretary of State to qualify an initiative to the ballot, relying on that ‘margin of error,’ ‘within the acceptable limits of the target,’ or any other similar statistical term, if the two statistical samplings done both produce estimates that the initiative petition was not ‘signed by a number of qualified voters equal [or greater than] six (6) percent of the total number of votes’ in the last gubernatorial election in Oregon?” (Brackets in original.)
The parties frame that question in the context of a challenge to the Secretary of State’s determination that initiative petition #53
1
contains the required number of valid signatures to qualify for placement on the November 1998 general election ballot. In determining that the petition contained the required number of valid signatures, the Secretary of State relied on what the parties refer to as the “margin of error” contained in OAR 165-014-0030, which provides that the Secretary of State will not exclude a petition for a proposed initiative from the ballot for insufficient signatures, unless statistical sampling shows that it is more than 80 percent likely that the petition lacks sufficient valid signatures.
2
Such reliance, plaintiffs claim, is impermissible, because of the requirement in Article IV, section l(2)(b), of the Oregon Constitution, that an initiative petition must contain a specified number of signatures in order to be placed on the ballot.
Plaintiffs Leo and Hymes brought this action in circuit court, alleging that the Secretary of State exceeded his
*560
authority by declaring that initiative petition #53 qualified for the November 1998 general election ballot. Plaintiffs sought a declaration that the petition “had insufficient signatures for placement on the ballot.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit