Appellate Court of Illinois August 7, 1998, 1-96-1695 (People v. Robinson)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-08-1998

SIXTH DIVISION FILED: 08/07/98 Nos. 1-96-1695, 1-96-2053, 1-96-3757, 1-97-3054, 1-97-3728 (Consolidated) THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS, ) Appeals from the ) Circuit Court of Plaintiff-Appellee, ) Cook County. ) ) v. ) ) ) WILL ROBINSON, JOHN DUNN, ) Honorable AMANDA WALLACE, GLENNON DYE & ) Themis Karnezis, Fred Suria, RAYMOND GOLDEN, ) Michael Bolan, Robert Krup ) & Rodolfo Garcia, Defendants-Appellants. ) Judges Presiding. JUSTICE ZWICK delivered the opinion of the court: These five criminal cases share a common procedural element. In all, the defendants died during the pendency of their appeals. Subsequently, counsel who had represented the defendants brought independent motions seeking to dismiss the appeals and to vacate the convictions, arguing that the cases had become moot upon their clients' deaths. The State agreed that the appeals were moot and that the appellate proceedings should be dismissed, but disagreed as to what effect dismissal would have upon the underlying convictions. Whereas defense counsel argued that the convictions should be voided as if they had never occurred ( ab initio , or literally, "from the beginning"), the State took the position that the defendants' convictions should be allowed to stand as a matter of record. We consolidated the cases and ordered the issue briefed and argued. We also ordered supplemental briefing following oral argument to address the impact of our State constitution's 1992 "victim's rights" amendment. See Ill. Const. 1970, Art. I, § 8.1. The effect of this amendment presents an issue of first impression. FACTS The underlying facts of the defendants' convictions can be briefly stated. Defendant Will Robinson, in appeal number 1-96-1695, was covicted of burglary. Officers testified that they observed Robinson in the act of removing a cellular telephone from the rear seat of a parked vehicle. Robinson was sentenced to serve 20 years in the custody of the Illinois Department of Corrections.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.