Ohio Court of Appeals August 10, 1998, No. CA97-11-222. (Hodges v. Meijer, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-08-1998
lead-opinion
William W. Young, Presiding Judge.
Plaintiff-appellant, Alladean Hodges, appeals the Butler County Court of Common Pleas decision granting the motion of defendant-appellee, Meijer, Inc., for summary judgment on her false imprisonment and defamation claims.
Appellant’s deposition reveals that on May 20, 1996, appellant entered the Hamilton Meijer store. She intended to do some grocery shopping and hoped to
*321
replace two Hoover vacuum sweeper belts. She brought her used belts in an Elder-Beerman bag with her for this purpose. Appellant showed the belts to a Meijer employee in the vacuum cleaner department. He advised her that Meijer did not carry them and suggested another store. Appellant continued with her shopping; at the end of an aisle she decided to put the bag containing the belts into her purse as she was afraid she might lose them. At that moment, appellant did not see the employee she had spoken with earlier.
After purchasing her groceries, but before exiting the store, appellant was approached by two Meijer employees. One stood in front of her and one stood in back. They said, “We’re going to take you back into the room.” Appellant asked, “Why?” and they said, “Don’t you know?” While walking to the office, appellant attempted to open her purse to produce her used belts. She was ordered not to take her hands off the cart.
In the office, appellant was permitted to show her belts and it was determined that they were not Meijer property. However, one of the belts was retained until the following week. Appellant was in the office for fifteen or twenty minutes. When she left, appellant was told not to return to Meijer. She was not touched by any Meijer employee. She did not see anyone she knew at the store, and she testified that, to her knowledge, no Meijer employee had discussed the incident with anyone.
On September 18, 1996, appellant filed her complaint against Meijer, raising claims sounding in false imprisonment and defamation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit