Ohio Court of Appeals June 5, 1998, No. F-97-025. (State v. Barker)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1998

lead-opinion

Handwork, Presiding Judge.

This is an appeal from judgment entries of the Fulton County Court, Eastern Division, in which the court (1) accepted jury verdicts finding appellant, Mary

*238

Barker, guilty of one count of resisting a lawful arrest,

1

guilty of six counts of cruelty to animals,

2

guilty of one count of failure to file an income tax return with the village of Swanton,

3

and guilty of two counts of petty theft, and (2) sentenced appellant for those crimes. Appellant has presented nine assignments of error for consideration on appeal, which read:

“I. Appellant Barker was not guilty of resisting arrest because her arrest for obstruction was unlawful, and she did not resist the arrest recklessly or by force.

“II. Finding appellant guilty of cruelty to animals was against the manifest weight of the evidence.

“III. Appellant Barker was not guilty of theft in case No.: CRB 00046-1.

“IV. Appellant Barker was not guilty of theft in case No.: CRB 00046-2.

‘V. The instructions to the jury were vague and confusing, and violated appellant’s due process rights.

“VI. Appellant Barker was not guilty of the city income tax charge.

“VII. Appellant cannot be ordered to serve time in jail.

“VIII. The sentence of the trial court was an abuse of discretion.

“IX. The trial court abused its discretion and violated the appellant’s right to due process of law, pursuant to the Constitutions of the United States of America and state of Ohio.”

Before we address the arguments presented by the parties relating to the various assignments of error, we will briefly review the facts in this case.

The record shows that appellant and her companion, Jose Vasquez, bred and sold dogs from their home in Swanton, Ohio. They kept a sign in their front yard that read, “Joe and Mary’s Petland.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.