Washington Supreme Court September 3, 1998, Nos. 65755-6; 65993-1 (In re the Recall of Pearsall-Stipek)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-09-1998
lead-opinion
Durham, C.J.
In these two consolidated cases, Mark Bennett appeals the Superior Court’s dismissals of his recall petitions against the Pierce County Auditor, Cathy Pearsall-Stipek. Mr. Bennett’s first recall petition makes the same charges based on the same facts as those brought in earlier recall petitions by another voter. The trial court dismissed these charges as barred by res judicata. We agree and affirm. Mr. Bennett’s second recall petition was dismissed for insufficiency. Additionally, the trial court found that the petition was frivolous and advanced without *259reasonable cause and ordered Mr. Bennett to pay Ms. Pearsall-Stipek’s reasonable attorney fees. We affirm the dismissal of the recall petition, but reverse the award of attorney fees.
Ms. Pearsall-Stipek was the subject of three earlier recall attempts by Dale Washam, which were dismissed as insufficient. These efforts culminated in In re Recall of Pearsall-Stipek, 129 Wn.2d 399, 918 P.2d 493 (1996), in which this court held that Mr. Washam’s successive identical recall petitions were barred by res judicata. Mr. Bennett’s first recall petition levies charges identical to those contained in Mr. Washam’s earlier recall petitions.1 Because Mr. Bennett did no more than present the same charges based on the same facts as Mr. Washam’s recall petitions, Judge Frederick B. Hayes of the Pierce County Superior Court held that all four charges were barred by res judicata. The court also reached the merits regarding three of the charges, ruling that they were insufficient to warrant submission to the voters. Mr. Bennett appealed directly to this court pursuant to RCW 29.82.160.
Mr. Bennett’s second recall petition charges Ms. Pearsall-Stipek with violating the free speech rights of candidates for the Tacoma City Council. These candidates submitted candidates’ statements for the local voters’ pamphlet in which they accused Ms.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit