Court of Appeals of Texas June 11, 1998, No. 14-96-01207-CV (Carpenter (Texas) Realty Corp. v. Allen Center Co. 4)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1998

lead-opinion

OPINION

EDELMAN, Justice.

Carpenter (Texas) Realty Corporation (“Carpenter”) appeals a judgment entered in favor of Allen Center Co. # 4, Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, and Metropolitan Tower Realty Company, Inc. (collectively “MetLife”) on the grounds that: (1) the trial court erred by permitting MetLife to elicit parol testimony concerning the intent of an unambiguous agreement; and (2) the jury’s verdict was against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence. We affirm.

Background

In 1986, Enron entered into a lease with MetLife (the “MetLife lease”) for office space in Four Allen Center, a building Met-Life owned in downtown Houston. The lease contained a twenty-year base term and six five-year renewal options. MetLife and Carpenter also entered into a commission agreement (the “commission agreement”) whereby Carpenter would be paid a commission on the aggregate rentals over the twenty year base term of the MetLife lease and for each renewal, extension, or expansion of it. In the event of a sale of Four Allen Center, MetLife would remain liable to Carpenter for future commissions unless MetLife arranged for the *810buyer to assume payment of those commissions.

Enron eventually occupied the entire Four Allen Center and agreed to buy it from Met-Life. However, to achieve “off balance sheet” financing, Enron structured the transaction so that a consortium of banks paid for the building, a trustee held title to it, and Enron leased the building from the trustee. In simultaneous transactions on September 27, 1991, the sale was closed for $281.5 million, Enron and MetLife terminated the Met-Life lease, and Enron entered into a three-year lease with the trustee.

MetLife agreed to pay Carpenter $5.75 million for the remaining commission on the base term of the MetLife Lease. However, Carpenter claimed that it was also entitled to commissions on rents for renewal periods, the value of which were reflected in the sale price of the building.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.