Court of Appeals of Utah July 16, 1998, No. 980014-CA (Miller v. State ex rel. Division of Consumer Protection)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-1998

BENCH, Judge:

David W. Miller, the guarantor on a bond, brings this appeal from a trial court’s order granting summary judgment to the appel-lees. The trial court awarded judgment against the issuer of the bond, Homestead Insurance Company and International Special Events & Recreation Association (Home*811stead), for the benefit of former members of Quest Sport & Fitness (Quest).1 We affirm,

FACTS

Country Court House Trust (CCH Trust) owned a health spa facility in South Jordan, Utah. CCH Trust leased the premises to Boyd Jentzseh, who operated the facility as Quest. Utah’s Health Spa Services Protection Act (the Act) requires spa operators to obtain a bond for the benefit of any consumer damaged by the closing of the business. See Utah Code Ann. § 13-23-5(2)(b) (1996). Accordingly, Quest sought a fifty thousand dollar bond from Homestead. Homestead issued the bond, but only after Quest secured Miller’s personal guarantee.

In 1995, Quest ceased doing business after filing for bankruptcy. The Utah Division of Consumer Protection (the Division) notified Homestead of Quest’s default and demanded payment on the bond. Five months after Quest’s closing, CCH Trust sold the facility to Salt Lake County (the County).

In August 1995, the Division filed an action on behalf of Quest members to recover the fifty thousand dollars under the Homestead bond. Thereafter, Miller filed an action against the Division and the County for declaratory and injunctive relief. Miller sought an order declaring that the rules promulgated under the Act require the County to honor the Quest membership contracts. Miller also sought an injunction to prevent the Division from collecting on the Homestead bond, pending the outcome of the declaratory action.

Miller’s action for declaratory and injunc-tive relief was later consolidated with the Division’s action to recover on the bond. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.