Court of Appeals of Georgia May 4, 1998, A98A0534 (Smith v. Linkwell Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-05-1998

Judge Harold R. Banke.

When Linkwell Industries, Inc. d/b/a Olympic Tires (“Linkwell”) sued for payment on a sales account, Richard O. Smith d/b/a Industrial Tire Service (“Smith”) counterclaimed for special and consequential damages. Smith does not contest the summary judgment regarding his indebtedness but challenges the dismissal of his counterclaim.1

The underlying action arose after Smith, who is in the business of selling and installing industrial grade forklift tires, purchased some defective tires from Linkwell. After Linkwell sued on the unpaid account balance, Smith counterclaimed for business losses allegedly sustained due to failure of a significant number of the tires. Linkwell argued that a limited warranty completely foreclosed Smith’s counterclaim. In dismissing Smith’s counterclaim, the trial court apparently agreed with Linkwell.

It is undisputed that Linkwell, a California corporation, supplied some defective tires to Smith’s Georgia business. Jackee Savage, Linkwell’s California-based credit manager, asserted that Smith received a limited warranty that expressly restricted Linkwell’s liability for the defective tires. This warranty provides, “[t]he buyer agrees that replacement or adjustment, as aforesaid, shall be the *439exclusive remedy and that Olympic Tyres shall not in any event be held liable for any special, indirect, or consequential damages.”2 Savage claimed that “[t]he warranty is printed on all sales literature and price lists.”

Smith’s testimony diametrically contradicted Savage’s version of events. Smith testified that at no time before commencing business with Linkwell had he been presented with a copy of the limited warranty at issue. Smith asserted that when he placed his orders by telephone to Linkwell’s Chattanooga facility, no mention was made of any limitation on liability and that he never consented to any such restriction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.