Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 3, 1998 (In re Poe Center)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-12-1998
OPINION OF THE COURT
Milonas, J. P.
The issue before us is the proper method to be used in the valuation of certain property in a condemnation proceeding commenced by the City of New York. The subject property consists of a parcel of land on which there is a four-story L-shaped building occupying less than a third of the site, with the majority of the site open space. Originally used as a home for the blind when first built, the property was purchased by the claimant real estate company in January 1971 for investment purposes and leased in April 1971 to the City for the Board of Higher Education’s use at an annual rent of $435,000; pursuant to the terms of the 10-year lease, claimant made certain alterations to the structure in order for it to be used as an educational facility by Lehman College. The lease, which *306was to expire in October 1981, offered a five-year renewal option to the tenant at a reduced annual rent of $252,000.
Shortly after the tenancy passed by operation of law from the Board of Higher Education to the City University (CUNY) in 1979, CUNY notified claimant that it would not exercise the renewal option. In January 1981, it sublet the property on a rent-free basis to the Board of Education for use as a public school annex. When the lease expired in October 1981, the subtenants remained and claimant commenced eviction proceedings, which became moot when the City acquired the property by condemnation on January 6, 1982. Claimant brought an action in the Court of Claims to recover compensation for the use and occupancy of the property during the brief holdover period; that court found claimant was entitled to recover the property’s fair market rental value for that period, which the court determined, using the terms of the lease’s renewal option, to be $252,000 a year (2641 Concourse Co. v City Univ., 137 Misc 2d 802, affd 147 AD2d 379 for reasons stated below).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit