Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 30, 1998 (City of New York v. Wing)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1998

OPINION OF THE COURT

Carpinello, J.

Pursuant to the Federal Adoption Assistance and Child Welfare Act of 1980 (see, 42 USC §§ 670-679), the State is entitled to be reimbursed with Federal funds for the foster care expenses of “[qualifying children” (42 USC § 672 [a]), which it then distributes to local social services districts, such as petitioner (see, Social Services Law § 153 et seq.). The present dispute has its genesis in a 1988 audit conducted by the United States Department of Health and Human Services (hereinafter HHS) of foster care expenditures incurred by petitioner between October 1983 and September 1985. Out of a statistical sample of 300 cases, the auditors determined that payments made in 202 of these cases should be disallowed for failing to meet various Federal eligibility requirements. On December 27, 1990, after extrapolating this case sample to the universe of foster care cases from which the sample was drawn and making adjustments based on submissions by respondent State Department of Social Services (hereinafter DSS), the number of children found to be ineligible was reduced to 186. Accordingly, HHS disallowed $92,115,289 in prior payments and sought recoupment of this sum from DSS. This figure was *175comprised of $64,123,732 in foster care maintenance payments and $27,991,567 in associated administrative costs.1

A two-step appeal process to the HHS Departmental Appeals Board (hereinafter DAB) ensued. Following completion of the first phase, which addressed the audit methodology, DAB upheld the entire disallowance for foster care maintenance payments in a decision dated September 30, 1992. The second phase, which addressed the propriety of the specific disallowances, proceeded in an informal manner during which DSS submitted offers of proof contesting 111 out of the 186 disallowed cases. A Congressional moratorium precluded HHS from responding to these submissions for over two years.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.