New York County Courts March 30, 1998 (Syracuse Housing Authority v. Boule)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-1998

OPINION OF THE COURT

J. Kevin Mulroy, J.

This is an appeal from a decision/order of the Syracuse City Court, dated December 23, 1996 (172 Misc 2d 254), dismissing the petitioner-appellant’s petition for recovery of real property from respondent, a public housing tenant. The stipulated facts are that on May 3, 1995, the respondent’s usual babysitter became unavailable and the respondent asked the father of her child to come to the premises which are the subject of the peti*401tion in order to care for the child while respondent worked. While respondent was at work, respondent’s child’s father invited two other people to the premises and they sold drugs from the premises and, as a result, were arrested. Petitioner, citing (among other cases) City of S. San Francisco Hous. Auth. v Guillory (49 Cal Rptr 2d 367, 41 Cal App 4th Supp 13) and Minneapolis Pub. Hous. Auth. v Holloway (1995 Minn App LEXIS 1028 [Minn Ct App, Aug. 15, 1995, Holtan, J.]), contends that a tenant can be evicted from public housing based on conduct which a tenant cannot reasonably foresee, prevent or control. The lower court disagreed, holding that when a public housing tenant is not personally at fault for the drug-related criminal activity of a guest, good cause for termination of the lease and eviction does not exist. Petitioner appeals from that determination.

Initially it should be noted, although apparently not within the petitioner’s scope of concern, this court finds that the result reached in the lower court is the only fair and just result under the circumstances present in this case. Furthermore, although the petitioner objected to the fact that the lower court failed to distinguish Guillory and Holloway (supra) from the instant case, this court believes that they are distinguishable.

The Guillory decision involved tenants who were evicted “for failure to assure that no drug-related criminal activity occur [red] in their premises” (City of S. San Francisco Hous. Auth.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.