Massachusetts Appeals Court December 10, 1998, No. 97-P-1513 (Wagley v. Danforth)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-12-1998

Gillerman, J.

In December, 1991, Elizabeth R. Evans (Evans), the owner of approximately seventy acres of registered land on Polpis Harbor, Nantucket (property), established the Nashayte Associates Limited Partnership (partnership) to which she conveyed the property. The general partners were Evans and her four children, John R. Wagley (John), Elizabeth W. Danforth (Danforth), Melinda Geddes (Geddes), and Galen Beale (Beale). Evans, her children, and grandchildren were the limited partners. Evans and each of her four children owned a one per cent general partnership share; Evans owned a 74.6 per cent limited partnership share.

After the death of Evans in June, 1995, a dispute arose as to whether the defendant general partners (defendants)3 — i.e., Danforth, Geddes, and Beale — had the authority under the limited partnership agreement (agreement) to sell the property without the approval of the plaintiffs Elizabeth H. Wagley (Elizabeth) and John R. Wagley, Jr. (John, Jr.). Elizabeth and John, Jr., are the children of the plaintiff John. They claim to be general partners by reason of the bankruptcy of their father, see note 12, infra, and they commenced this action in the Land Court to enforce their alleged right to object to the proposed sale.

A judge of that court allowed a motion for summary judgment (filed originally as a motion to dismiss) in favor of the defendants, and this appeal followed.4

The defendants claim that under the provisions of the partnership agreement, they rightfully accepted, on behalf of the partnership, an offer to purchase the property dated August 8, *171996, for $7,200,000. That claim is at the center of this controversy. We set forth certain undisputed material facts.

The property was first listed for sale with real estate brokers on April 19, 1996, for $7,800,000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.