Court of Appeals of Arkansas March 25, 1998, CA 97-910 (Smith v. Riceland Foods, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-03-1998

lead-opinion

Sam Bird, Judge.

Charles D. Smith appeals a decision of the Workers’ Compensation Commission holding that he had failed to prove by a preponderance of the credible evidence that he injured his back in a compensable fall that occurred on September 20, 1994. Appellant argues the decision is not supported by substantial evidence.

The appellant, a thirty-six-year-old man, was injured when a “man-lift” he was riding broke, and he fell thirty-five to forty feet. At first all he could feel was his legs hurting “real bad,” and he couldn’t get up. Appellant was immobilized and taken by ambulance to the emergency room at the University of Arkansas Medical Center (UAMS) where it was determined that his only injury was to his right knee. He was hospitalized overnight and sent home the next day in a thigh-to-ankle brace.

Appellant testified that he took physical therapy for several months and throughout that entire time he was telling his doctor, his physical therapist, and Ms. Judy Nelson, a nurse identified in a letter as the case manager for Systemedic Corporation who telephoned him to check on his progress, that he was having pain in his lower back. Dr. J. Michael Gruenwald, an orthopaedist and knee specialist, referred him to Dr. Glen Pait, a neurosurgeon. From x-rays Dr. Pait diagnosed appellant with degenerative disc disease of “obscure etiology.” Appellant said after his visit to Dr. Pait nothing more was said or done about his back.

Appellant was released to return to light-duty work on May 25, 1995. Appellee placed him in a small air-conditioned room called a scale room where he weighed incoming and outgoing trucks and dumped the load on incoming trucks by controlling levers in the office.

Appellant recounted that one morning in early June 1995, as he was leaving for work, his porch was wet with dew, his cane slipped, and he fell on his buttocks.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.