United States Court of International Trade February 6, 1998, Court No. 95-10-01273 (United States v. Hi-Temp Specialty Metals, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-02-1998

Memorandum Opinion

Goldberg, Judge:

Currently pending before this Court is the defendant’s, Hi-Temp, Inc.’s (“Hi-Temp”), Motion for Attorney’s Fees pur*52suant to USCIT R. 37(a)(3). Hi-Temp seeks reimbursement for the cost of litigating plaintiffs, the United States Customs Service’s (“Customs”), July 21,1997, Motionfor Protective Order, a motion that sought to prevent Hi-Temp from deposing certain Customs officials pursuant to USCIT R. 26(c). This Court denied plaintiffs motion in an Order dated September 24,1997. In its Motion for Attorney’s Fees, Hi-Temp claims that plaintiffs Motion for Protective Order was not substantially justified. For the reasons set forth below, this Court finds unpersuasive plaintiffs argument that it was substantially justified in seeking the protective order and, hence, grants Hi-Temp the reasonable costs incurred in litigating this matter.

Background

The underlying case involves a penalty action brought by Customs against Hi-Temp pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1592 (1994). The penalty action pertains to four entries, three entered in the port of Baltimore, Maryland and one entered in the Port of San Francisco, California. Hi-Temp represented that all four entries were duty-free titanium scrap from Sweden. In Baltimore, Customs accepted this description, and liquidated these three entries accordingly In San Francisco, however, Customs determined that the entry was not titanium scrap from Sweden but actually titanium sponge from the Soviet Union. Customs then liquidated the San Francisco entry accordingly. Hi-Temp responded by filing an administrative protest challenging this classification, which Customs denied. Hi-Temp did not seek judicial review of the denial of its protest. Pursuantto 19 U.S.C. § 1592, Customs then brought the instant action against Hi-Temp to collect penalties, claiming that Hi-Temp knowingly imported titanium sponge from the Soviet Union and listed it as titanium scrap from Sweden.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.