Ohio Supreme Court December 9, 1998, No. 98-824 (Cincinnati Bar Ass'n v. Bertsche)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-12-1998
Per Curiam.
We adopt the findings of the board. Especially troubling to us, as it was to the bankruptcy court in Cincinnati, is respondent’s receipt of funds from Associates upon the refinancing of his clients’ real estate. As that court observed, respondent was either charging his clients fees for finding appropriate financing, in which case he failed to file the necessary fee applications with the bankruptcy court, or respondent was receiving finder’s fees from Associates for bringing clients to it, in which case respondent was representing Associates and was in a conflict-of-interest situation.
Even if we accept respondent’s argument that he represented his Chapter 13 clients in the refinancings, we cannot adopt his 'conclusion that he could set fees unilaterally and that fee applications and disclosures were not necessary. EC 2-18 of our Ethical Considerations provides that an attorney should reach a full and clear agreement with his client about the basis of his fee before he undertakes the work. Yet respondent did not tell his clients that he would receive a fee for negotiating their loans with Associates. It was only at the time when the loans were closed that respondent’s clients, eager to complete the transactions and exit from Chapter 13, were informed that a fee for respondent would be added to their loans. Predictably, they ■ did not object. This situation is similar to Columbus Bar Assn. v. Zauderer (1997), 80 Ohio St.3d 435, 438, 687 N.E.2d 410, 412-413, in which we suspended an attorney who, in control of settlement funds, attempted a unilateral alteration of his contingent fee contracts with his clients before disbursing the money.
Moreover, as Bankruptcy Judge Vincent Aug observed at the en banc hearing in bankruptcy court, the bankruptcy process is, in part, a process to protect debtors. “And judges * * * look to see whether or not a person is doing something that is unwise * * *.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit