Court of Appeals of Washington January 26, 1998, No. 35689-5-I (Gilliam v. Department of Social & Health Services)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-01-1998

lead-opinion

Becker, J.

Richard Gilliam’s ex-wife initiated a Child Protective Services (CPS) investigation against him in May, 1985, alleging that their two children reported being sexually molested by Gilliam. Gilliam initially stipulated to an order of dependency barring him from any visitation with the children. Eventually, however, the dependency was dismissed, and Gilliam received custody of the children.

Gilliam sued the State and the CPS caseworker, claiming the caseworker’s inadequate investigation of the allegations inordinately prolonged the dependency proceedings *572and his separation from his children, resulting in mental anguish and expenses.1 After Gilliam rested his case, the State moved for a directed verdict on the basis that the State and the caseworker were entitled to absolute immunity. The trial court granted the motion,2 and dismissed the suit. Gilliam appeals from that ruling.

We are asked to decide whether an absolute immunity shields the State from a suit for damages caused by a caseworker’s negligent investigation conducted after the filing of a dependency action. The State claims the caseworker’s actions were entitled to absolute immunity because they were functionally like a prosecutor’s, and because the adversarial nature of the judicial process provided Gilliam with opportunity to challenge any of the caseworker’s representations or recommendations. We conclude the conduct complained of was investigative in nature, and insufficiently tied to the judicial process to warrant a grant of absolute immunity. Accordingly, we reverse the order directing a verdict for the State.

FACTS

Richard Gilliam and his wife, Ruby, divorced in 1982. The decree provided that their son and daughter would live with Ruby, and Richard would have visitation rights. Ruby then married Yvain Stansberry.

On May 17, 1985, Ruby Stansberry reported to Child Protective Services that the children, four and five years of age, said Gilliam had sexually abused them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.