Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit July 6, 1998, Nos. 97-35197, 97-35312 (Star Phoenix Mining Co. v. West One Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-07-1998

LAY, Circuit Judge:

Debtor Star Phoenix Mining Company (“Star Phoenix”) and its owners, Frank and Janice Duval, appeal the district court’s order affirming the bankruptcy court’s denial of permanent injunctive relief in them adversary proceeding against creditor West One Bank (“West One”). West One cross-appeals the district court’s denial of attorneys’ fees. We dismiss the cross-appeal on attorney fees as premature, we otherwise affirm.

Star Phoenix was formed in 1989 to mine certain property in Burke, Idaho. To open its facilities, Star Phoenix borrowed $2 million from Comineo Limited. Under the loan agreements, Comineo required Star Phoenix to obtain a $1 million operating line of credit. Star Phoenix obtained the required line of credit from West One. West One in turn required the Duvals to personally guarantee the full $1 million revolving line of credit. West One’s line of credit to Star Phoenix was also secured by an interest in certain accounts receivable of Star Phoenix.

In November 1990, Star Phoenix’s mine lease was terminated, which placed Star Phoenix in default under its agreement with West One. On March 11, 1991, the Duvals confessed judgment in favor of West One in state court based on their personal guaranty in the amount of $1,029,134.9s.1 On March 18, 1991, Star Phoenix filed for Chapter 11 relief.

During the bankruptcy proceedings, West One filed a proof of claim based upon the $1 million line of credit secured by the accounts receivable. The proposed reorganization plan provided that the secured creditors, including West One, would not be entitled to a deficiency claim unless the bankruptcy court determined such a claim existed prior to the effective date of the plan. The plan also stated that upon confirmation of the plan, the secured creditors would have no further claims against Star Phoenix unless the creditor asserted an unsecured deficiency claim prior to confirmation. The bankruptcy court confirmed the plan on August 11, 1992.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.