Indiana Court of Appeals September 25, 1998, No. 49A02-9711-CV-793 (State v. Person)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1998
OPINION
STATON, Judge.
The State of Indiana and the Speedway Police Department (“the State”) appeal an order requiring them to pay attorney’s fees incurred by Thomas Person in a civil forfeiture proceeding. The dispositive issue presented is whether, following an unsuccessful civil forfeiture action, the trial court had the authority to assess attorney’s fees against the State under Indiana’s General Recovery Rule.
We reverse.
This case arose when, on October 30, 1996, Speedway Police Officer James Hornaday stopped Person for speeding. An examination of Person’s driving record revealed that his license had been suspended, and Officer Hornaday arrested Person. While conducting a search incident to the arrest, the officer discovered that Person was carrying two pagers and $2,929.00 in United States currency. A second Speedway police officer testified that Person admitted he had obtained the money from a “pea-shake house,” apparently a gambling establishment.
On December 31, 1996, the State filed a complaint seeking forfeiture of the $2,929.00.1 At trial, Person explained he was carrying the cash from two payroll checks totaling approximately $1,300.00 and taking it “downtown” to settle a disagreement about a child support arrearage. Person did not explain the source of the other funds but testified his reported 1996 gross income was $12,689.86. The trial court ruled in favor of Person, stating:
The evidence I heard from that police officer was that the defendant said he got the money in a pea-shake house. There’s no testimony he got it gambling, stealing it, selling drugs or any illegal activity. Being in a pea-shake house is not sufficient.
Record at 128. The court then ordered the $2,929.00 released to Person.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit