Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces January 14, 1998, No. 96-1178; Crim.App. No. 95-0967 (United States v. Sylvester)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-01-1998
Opinion of the Court
EFFRON, Judge:
A special court-martial composed of a military judge sitting alone convicted appellant, pursuant to his pleas, of -wrongful use and wrongful distribution of methamphetamine, in violation of Article 112a, Uniform Code of Military Justice, 10 USC § 912a. He was sentenced to a bad-conduct discharge, confinement for 90 days, forfeiture of $250.00 pay per month for 3 months, and reduction to the lowest enlisted grade. The convening authority approved these results, and the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the findings and sentence in an unpublished opinion.
We specified the following issues for review:
I. WHETHER APPELLANT WAS DENIED EFFECTIVE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL DURING POST-TRIAL PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE CONVENING AUTHORITY WHERE:
(A) CIVILIAN DEFENSE COUNSEL AGREED TO ACCEPT SERVICE OF THE AUTHENTICATED RECORD OF TRIAL AND THE STAFF JUDGE ADVOCATE’S RECOMMENDATION, BUT FAILED TO SUBMIT MATTER IN SUPPORT OF CLEMENCY UNDER ARTICLE 60, UCMJ, AND RCM 1105 AND 1106 DESPITE APPELLANT’S DESIRE TO PURSUE CLEMENCY;
(B) THE UNREBUTTED AFFIDAVITS CONSIDERED BY THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS STATE THAT DETAILED DEFENSE COUNSEL DID NOT RETURN CALLS FROM APPELLANT PRIOR TO THE CONVENING AUTHORITY’S ACTION AND THERE IS NO INDICATION IN THE RECORD THAT DETAILED DEFENSE COUNSEL WAS RELIEVED OF HIS POST-TRIAL RESPONSIBILITIES TO APPELLANT; AND
(C) DESPITE THE FACT THAT THE UNREBUTTED AFFIDAVITS REFLECT CIVILIAN DEFENSE COUNSEL’S BELIEF THAT THE CONVENING AUTHORITY HAD A PREDISPOSITION TO NOT GRANT POST-TRIAL CLEMENCY, THE CIVILIAN DEFENSE COUNSEL DID NOT TAKE STEPS TO HAVE THE POST-TRIAL ACTION TAKEN BY A DIFFERENT CONVENING AUTHORITY.
II. WHETHER THE RECORD IS INCOMPLETE IN THAT THE CONVENING AUTHORITY’S ACTION DOES NOT REFLECT THE MATTER DESCRIBED IN THE UNREBUTTED AFFIDAVITS CONSIDERED BY THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS WHICH STATE THAT CLEMENCY AND DEFERMENT REQUESTS WERE PRESENTED ORALLY TO THE CONVENING AUTHORITY.
III.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit