Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit August 10, 1998, 97-4098 (Richard Bednar, Jr. Laura Bednar, Individually and as Next Friends of Marian Kristen Bednar v. Bassett Furniture Manufacturing Company, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-08-1998

MURPHY, Circuit Judge.

Richard and Laura Bednar brought this action against Bassett Furniture Manufacturing, Inc., (Bassett) based on diversity of citizenship, 28 U.S.C. § 1332, alleging that a dresser it had manufactured emitted dangerous levels of formaldehyde which injured their baby, Marian Kristen. They appeal from a summary judgment in favor of Bas-sett. We reverse and remand.

The Bednars purchased the Bassett dresser from Montgomery Ward prior to the birth of Marian for the room they were preparing for the expected baby. They installed the dresser in the room and put various baby clothes, linens, and blankets in it. Several family members noticed the dresser had what they described as a “new” smell. Marian was born on September 26,1994 with no health problems and was taken to her room at home a few days later. The noticeable odor was still coming

from the

dresser, and by this time it had permeated the clothes and linens stored in it.

Marian soon began to suffer from unusually rapid breathing and redness in her eyes. Despite repeated visits, to the doctor, the problems persisted and the Bednars began to suspect that they were related to the dresser. In late November Marian’s breathing problems worsened and caused her parents to take her to the hospital and to contact poison control. They removed the dresser from Marian’s room when they returned from the hospital, and her respiratory difficulty and ,eye inflammation began to subside. She was nevertheless hospitalized again on December 1, and she continued to suffer chronic kidney infections that did not respond to normal antibiotic treatments and she developed reactive asthma and gastrointestinal reflux. The Bednars noticed that Marian seemed irritable and hyperactive, grew quite slowly, and developed several allergies that required almost daily shots to control.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.