Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit July 15, 1998, 97-1492 (In Re Denis Rouffet, Yannick Tanguy and Frederic Berthault)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-07-1998
RADER, Circuit Judge.
Denis Rouffet, Yannick Tanguy, and Fréd-éric Bethault (collectively, Rouffet) submitted application 07/888,791 (the application) on May 27, 1992. The Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (the Board) affirmed final rejection of the application as obvious under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a).
See Ex parte Rouffet,
No. 96-1553 (Bd. Pat.App. & Int. Apr. 16, 1997). Because the Board reversibly erred in identifying a motivation to combine the references, this court reverses.
I.
Satellites in a geosynchronous or geostationary orbit remain over the same point on the Earth’s surface. Their constant position above the Earth’s surface facilitates communications. These satellites project a number of beams to the Earth. Each beam transmits to its area of coverage, or footprint, on the Earth’s surface. In order to provide complete coverage, adjacent footprints overlap slightly and therefore must use different frequencies to avoid interference. However, two or more non-overlapping footprints can use the same set of frequencies in order to use efficiently the limited radio spectrum. Figure 1 from the application shows the coverage of a portion of the Earth’s surface provided by multiple cone shaped beams:
*1353
[[Image here]]
Frequency reuse techniques, however, have a limited ability to compensate for congestion in geostationary orbits. To alleviate the orbit congestion problem, new telecommunications systems use a network of satellites in low Earth orbit. When viewed from a fixed point on the Earth’s surface, such satellites do not remain stationary but move overhead. A satellite’s motion as it transmits a plurality of cone-shaped beams creates a new problem. The satellite’s movement causes a receiver on the Earth’s surface to move from the footprint of one beam into a second beam transmitted by the same satellite.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit