Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit October 27, 1998, 98-1333 (United States v. Raymond Aghedo)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1998

RIPPLE, Circuit Judge.

Raymond Aghedo was charged in an indictment with using the mail to defraud and with possessing credit cards with intent to defraud. The district court denied Mr. Agh-edo’s motion to suppress a notebook obtained in the warrantless search of the apartment where Mr. Aghedo was staying. A jury found Mr. Aghedo guilty, and he now appeals the district court’s denial of his motion.

I

BACKGROUND

A. Facts

FBI agents obtained a warrant for Mr. Aghedo’s arrest, naming him as part of a heroin distribution conspiracy. Although the warrant related only to drug distribution, the FBI agents also possessed evidence of Mr. Aghedo’s credit card fraud, which they turned over to postal investigators.

Thereafter, pursuant to the warrant, the investigators arrested Mr. Aghedo in the lobby of an apartment building. For reasons undisclosed by the record, Mr. Aghedo accompanied the FBI agents and postal investigators to another apartment building, and then to an apartment in that building, which was leased in the name of Adeniji Dairo. Dairo told the officers that Mr. Aghedo was a guest in her apartment. She signed a form, allowing the officers to search the entire apartment, including the room where Mr. Aghedo was staying. The apartment had two bedrooms — one occupied by Mr. Aghedo and one occupied by Dairo and her children. Although he was present when Dairo signed the consent form, Mr. Aghedo did not object to her consent.

After entering the open door of Mr. Aghe-do’s room, the officers found and seized a black and white composition notebook from under the box spring and mattress. The notebook contained several hundred credit card account numbers and social security numbers.

Mr. Aghedo had been staying with Dairo rent-free for approximately six months. Mr. Aghedo’s brother was the father of one of Dairo’s children; During Mr. Aghedo’s stay in Dairo’s apartment, she had free access to Mr. Aghedo’s room, which was never locked.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.