Supreme Court of Alabama January 28, 1998, 1970044 (Hunter v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1998

lead-opinion

BUTTS, Justice.

PETITION DENIED.

ALMON, SHORES, KENNEDY, and COOK, JJ., concur.

HOOPER, C. J., and MADDOX, HOUSTON, and SEE, JJ., dissent.

dissent

HOOPER, Chief Justice

(dissenting).

I must respectfully dissent from this Court’s denial of a writ of certiorari. Renea Hunter signed a form stating:

“I have been informed by my State Farm agent that the Company does not intend to reinstate this policy so as to provide coverage during the period that the policy was out of force.

It is therefore understood and agreed that receipt of this remittance does not reinstate the insurance prior to _ (time) AM PM_(date).”

She now claims to have no recollection of this form, even though she admits that it is her signature on the document.

The language quoted here clearly conveyed the fact that the Hunters’ coverage was not retroactive and that Greg Hunter’s automobile accident would therefore not be covered. By signing this form, Ms. Hunter agreed that State Farm would not be responsible for any claims that had arisen after the policy had lapsed. No breach of contract could have occurred, because Renea Hunter’s signature provides objective proof that State Farm had no duty to pay the claim. State Farm could not have fraudulently suppressed the fact that it would not pay the claim, because the form Renea Hunter signed clearly disclosed that fact. As a matter of law, therefore, *435there can be no issue of material fact as to her claims of fraud and breach of contract; the trial court correctly entered the summary judgment as to these claims.

The Hunters are not the first plaintiffs who have entered a contract and then tried to back out of it by claiming ignorance of its contents. In the past, this Court has not allowed a party to avoid the obligations imposed by a contract he or she has signed. In Locklear Dodge City, Inc. v. Kimbrell, 703 So.2d 303 (Ala.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.