Louisiana Court of Appeal March 11, 1998, No. 97-C-2535 (Mayer v. Laniri)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-03-1998
lead-opinion
JiBYRNES, Judge.
Plaintiffs, Deborah Mayer, wife of/and Walter Mayer and Linda Mixon wife of/and Jerry Mixon, filed suit following a ear accident February 7, 1997. Named as defendants were the driver of the other car, defendant Joel Laniri (Laniri); the insurer of that car, American Deposit Insurance Company, relator herein; and the plaintiff driver’s UM Carrier, State Farm. The relator, American Deposit Insurance Company, filed a motion for summary judgment arguing a policy exclusion for uninsured drivers. That exclusion states that the policy will not apply to, “Bodily injury or property damage caused by your insured car if driven by an unlicensed driver ...”
The driver of the offending vehicle, the defendant Joel Laniri, lives at home with his mother who is the owner of the vehicle. Laniri was allegedly on an errand for her at the time of the accident. The relator, American Deposit, supported its motion for summary judgment with three documents in an attempt that Laniri’s driver’s license had expired. First, relator presented Laniri’s statement to relator’s claims adjuster that his driver’s license had expired in May of 1996, that it simply needed to be renewed, that he did not know it had expired, and that he thought the license was good until May of 1998. ^Plaintiffs’ opposition to the motion in the trial court challenges this statement on the basis that it was not under oath. Second, relator presented an affidavit of the adjuster that she had recorded Laniri’s statement. Plaintiffs’ opposition to the motion filed in the trial court challenges this affidavit on the basis that it is hearsay and not based on first hand knowledge as required. Third, relator presented a certified copy of Laniri’s driving record from the Department of Motor Vehicles establishing that his license had indeed expired on May 29, 1996. Plaintiffs’ opposition to relator’s motion did not challenge this document.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit