District Court of Appeal of Florida June 24, 1998, No. 97-2547 (Union American Insurance Co. v. Cabrera)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-06-1998

lead-opinion

COPE, Judge.

Union American Insurance Company appeals an adverse judgment in an uninsured motorist coverage (“UM”) case. We reverse.

Plaintiff-appellee Juan B. Cabrera was the owner of his own trucking rig, and obtained trucking work through Truck Brokerage By National (“TBBN”). Plaintiff was required to carry liability insurance. He could either purchase his own policy or opt to be covered by TBBN’s business auto policy. Plaintiff chose the TBBN policy which was written by defendant-appellant Union American.

In May 1994, plaintiff was in an accident with an uninsured motorist. He sought UM benefits from under the TBBN policy, but the policy provided no UM coverage.

Plaintiff brought suit for UM benefits, contending that there had been no proper rejection of UM coverage by the named insured, TBBN. See § 627.727(1), Fla. Stat. From a jury verdict in favor of Cabrera, the insurer appeals.

We conclude that the judgment must be reversed on account of faulty jury instructions. The issue in the ease was whether TBBN, the insured named in the policy, see id., had rejected UM coverage. The statute requires a written rejection. See id. However, under the case law it is also permissible for an insurer to “avoid the statutorily required [UM] coverage if it proves that the named insured orally waived the statutory requirement of a written rejection by knowingly selecting a lesser limit or by knowingly rejecting UM coverage.” Chmieloski v. National Union Fire Insurance Co., 563 So.2d 164, 166 (Fla. 2d DCA 1990) (citation omitted).1

The policy in this case had been issued in 1986 and, according to the insurer, documents pertaining to the original issuance of the insurance policy had been destroyed under its records retention policy. Thus, the written rejection could not be produced in the lawsuit. Although the document itself could not be produced, the insurer adduced testimony at trial that there had been both written and oral rejections of UM coverage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.