Supreme Court of Alabama February 20, 1998, 1960917 (Crumpton v. McDowell)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-02-1998

On Application for Rehearing

HOOPER, Chief Justice.

This Court’s opinion of December 19, 1997, is withdrawn, and the following is substituted therefor.

This case involves the release of an executor from liability after a partial distribution of the estate. The Court of Civil Appeals reversed the portion of the order of the Jefferson County Probate Court that relieved Harry McDowell, as executor of the estate of James S. Crumpton, from liability for the period during which he was involved in a proposed sale of the decedent’s company, the Crumpton Sprinkler Company, a corporation. Crumpton v. McDowell, 721 So.2d 690 (Ala.Civ.App.1996). The Court of Civil Appeals affirmed part of the probate judge’s ruling. It determined that the trial judge correctly found that McDowell did not breach his fiduciary duty. However, it reversed the portion of the trial judge’s order that relieved McDowell of liability for the period in question. The Court of Civil Appeals also affirmed an award of fees to McDowell and his attorney. We address the portion of the Court of Civil Appeals’ judgment that reversed McDowell’s release from liability.

We hold that the probate court correctly determined that McDowell should be relieved of liability for the period in question. Thus, the judgment of the Court of Civil Appeals is reversed as to the liability issue.

McDowell is the executor of the estate of James Crumpton; Oscar Crumpton and Marlene Wood are residuary beneficiaries. McDowell’s handling of James Crumpton’s company after Crumpton’s death is the subject of this dispute. McDowell was the president of the company. James Crumpton requested that the business not be liquidated following his death and stated his preference that it continue to operate. As an alternative to dissolution and liquidation, McDowell and other employees proposed to buy the company.

This dispute arose when the proposed sale of the company was rejected by the beneficiaries of Crumpton’s estate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.