District Court of Appeal of Florida December 9, 1998, Nos. 97-03277, 97-04088 (CHS Financial Services, Inc. v. Small Business Consultants, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1998

QUINCE, Judge.

This case arises out the alleged violation of a noncompetition agreement between Small Business Consultants (SBC) and Carmie H. Snider (Snider), entered into on February 8, 1993, while Snider was associated with SBC. The narrow issue presented in this appeal is whether Snider, now the principal of his own loan company, CHS Financial Services, Inc. (CHS), violated the noncompetition agreement by directly soliciting SBC’s customer, Century Bank, with regard to the Suntan Terrace Motel transaction. We find there was no direct solicitation and reverse the award of damages, fees and costs.

SBC is in the business of obtaining Small Business Administration (SBA) loans for its business customers. These loans are obtained through lending institutions, which also provide loans to other businesses and individuals as well as to SBC. SBC also acts as a consultant to small lending institutions, by processing and submitting loans to the SBA for approval. SBC had such a consulting agreement with Century Bank. From February 8, 1983, to September 1, 1994, Snider worked as an independent contractor for SBC pursuant to an independent contractor agreement and addendum thereto, which contained a noncompete provision. On September 1, 1994, Snider and SBC terminated the independent contractor agreement by executing a termination agreement. The latter agreement reiterated the terms of the non-compete provisions of the original agreement.

Prior to the present dispute, SBC and Century Bank had worked together on a project known as Suntan Terrace. The previous owner of Suntan Terrace, Biscardi, wanted to finance the purchase of the motel with a SBA loan. SBC and Snider gathered and analyzed the necessary financial information for submission of the loan request to the SBA. When Century Bank decided not to close on the loan to Biscardi, SBC requested that Century Bank transfer the loan to Sarasota Bank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.