Louisiana Court of Appeal December 28, 1998, No. 97 CA 2644 (Stalter v. Banker Multiple Line Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-1998

2SHORTESS, C.J.

Can the words “I’ll look into it” obligate a real estate broker to perform certain services? That is the issue before the court in this case.

Brewster Stalter, II, and his brother Rowland Stalter (plaintiffs) sued John T. Wood, a real estate broker; John T. Wood Properties, Wood’s sole proprietorship; and Banker Multiple Line Insurance Company, Wood’s errors and omissions insurer. Plaintiffs alleged Wood agreed to “look into” a piece of property for them but failed to do so, thereby depriving them of the opportunity to bid on and purchase the property.

The trial court found Wood had breached no duty toward plaintiffs and that there was never a meeting of the minds between the parties to form a contract. The court dismissed plaintiffs’ suit, and they appeal.

Plaintiffs and their sisters, through a trust, owned a 41-acre tract in Lacombe. Plaintiffs bought a 159-acre tract surrounding their original tract. Wood was the listing agent on the 159-acre tract. On March 6, 1993, after the purchase agreement was signed but before the act of sale was executed, Wood met plaintiffs to walk over the property. While driving to the property, a discussion ensued about a piece of property that appeared to be adjacent to the 159-acre tract. Plaintiffs expressed an interest in buying the tract when it became available for sale if it adjoined their property. Wood told them he thought it would be available soon and agreed “to look into it.”

Although the Stalter brothers were also licensed real estate brokers, they were busy and thought it would be easier to have Wood research the property for them. Rowland testified he called Wood seven or eight times between March 6 and April 14, primarily to discuss the closing on the 159-acre tract, but he mentioned the 25-acre tract during two or three of those calls. Each time, Wood told him he would look into it. Brewster testified he talked to Wood on the telephone two or three times about the 25-acre tract.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.