Louisiana Court of Appeal December 9, 1998, Nos. 98-CA-1035, 98-CA-1036, 98-CA-1037, 98-CA-1038 (Shephard ex rel. Shephard v. Scheeler)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-12-1998
lead-opinion
LWALTZER, Judge.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On 6 July 1987, Alfred Scheeler lost control of his truck after hitting a puddle of water on Louisiana Highway 39 in St. Bernard Parish (Parish). The truck, carrying three young boys, struck a stopped Parish garbage truck driven by Wallace Couture and occupied by Roland Rossignol and Henry J. Rogers, all of whom were employed by the Parish. Five suits were filed, and, following a bifurcated trial, a liability judgment was rendered on 20 March 1995. On appeal, this Court rendered an opinion on 8 May 1996. The Louisiana Supreme Court granted writs, and amended this Court’s opinion, recasting fault in the following proportions: Alfred Scheeler 80% and St. Bernard Parish Police Jury 20%, and remanded the case to the trial court.
In the interim, the trial court tried the damage issues, awarding damages to Mr. and Mrs: Michael Shepard in the amounts of $505,583.76 for Matthew Shephard’s wrongful death and $40,000 for Matthew’s survival action; to Alfred Scheeler in the amount of $425,765.10; to Wallace Couture in the amount of $244,137.33 and to Roland Rossignol in the amount of $244,831.29. On appeal, this Court reduced the award for Matthew Shepard’s survival action to $7500; reduced Alfred Scheeler’s award to $418,765.10; reduced Wallace Couture’s award to $219,137.33 and reduced Roland Rossignol’s award to $194,831.29. In all other respects, we affirmed the judgment of the trial court.
|2On remand from the Louisiana Supreme Court, the trial court on 15 January 1998 rendered judgment dismissing all claims against the State of Louisiana through the Department of Transportation and Development; amending this Court’s decree to cast Alfred Scheeler to be 80% at fault and the Parish Police Jury to be 20% at fault; dismissing Couture’s and Rossig-nol’s claims due to settlement; awarding Alfred Scheeler $83,753.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit