District Court of Appeal of Florida July 29, 1998, Nos. 96-3144, 97-0368 (Anchor Bank, S.S.B. v. Conrardy)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-07-1998

STONE, Chief Judge.

We affirm a final judgment that rescinds Appellees’ purchase of a condominium apartment unit and orders payment of incidental damages.

In addition to seeking the equitable relief of rescission based on Appellant’s misrepresentations, Appellees-purchasers sued Appellant-developer for fraud based on false representations and failure to disclose known construction defects, including serious structural rust corrosion problems, in the condominium building. The rescission and fraud claims were tried together with a jury. The trial court entered a directed verdict on the common law fraud claims, finding deficiencies in proof as to the tort damages. The court proceeded on the rescission claim, and the jury entered a special interrogatory verdict on the rescission issues, upon which the court entered the judgment.

The jury found that Appellant’s intentional and negligent misrepresentations of material facts induced Appellees to purchase the unit, that Appellees were unaware of the falsity of the representations, that Appellant intentionally faded to disclose material facts in order to induce the purchase, and that Appellees were not aware of the undisclosed facts. The jury also determined that Appellees were able to restore Appellant to the status quo existing when the unit was purchased notwithstanding a deterioration in its value during the intervening period, as the loss in value had resulted from the undisclosed facts.

Following the verdict, the trial court held a hearing on the rescission claim and found that Appellees had no adequate remedy at law. The court applied the jury’s findings and determined, inter alia, that Appellees were entitled to incidental damages. The trial court also recognized that Appellant would have been entitled to a set-off for rental value, but declined to enter such an award due to lack of credible evidence.

Appellant contends that Appel-lees’ rescission claim must fail because Ap-pellees had an adequate remedy at law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.