Massachusetts Superior Court December 9, 1998, No. 960945A (Glidden v. Maglio)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1998

van Gestel, J.

This matter is before the Court on motions for summary judgment filed by the defendant, Nicholas Magiio (“Magiio”), against all plaintiffs in these two consolidated actions. For the reasons stated, the motions are ALLOWED.

*456BACKGROUND

The following facts are not in dispute. Maglio owned a three-family house on Rantoul Street in Beverly where he lived in one of the apartments and leased the other two apartments to members of the public. Maglio had need to have a roof leak repaired. He learned that one of his tenants, Gary Glidden (“Gary”), brother of the plaintiff, Brian Glidden (“Brian”), in case No. 96-0945, did roofing work and solicited from Gary a bid for the job. Gary’s bid, after some negotiation, was accepted by Maglio.

Gary was not a contractor, but rather was interested in the work to earn some extra money on the weekends. Gary engaged his brother Brian, the plaintiff John Strong (“Strong”) in case No. 97-0589, and another man to assist in the work. Maglio, apparently, had involvement in setting the hourly rates to be paid these workers.

Maglio selected the kind and color of the roofing shingles to be used on the job.

Prior to the start of work, Gary told Maglio that he, Maglio, had to secure the building permit because Gary was a noncontractor and only a homeowner or a contractor could pull a permit. Although Maglio told Gary that he had obtained the permit, in fact he had neglected to do so.

Staging or scaffolding was needed for some of the work. Maglio expressed concern about ladders being utilized in the driveway beside the building because of their interference with his and the neighbors’ access. In response Gary determined to use pump-jack scaffolding. Both Gary and Strong had had prior experience with pump-jack scaffolding, although Strong would have preferred ladder jacks because there was no wood involved in their construction.

Gary supplied all of the labor, materials, and equipment for the roofing job.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.