Indiana Supreme Court October 21, 1998, 53A01-9801-CV-31 (Francis v. Yates)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1998

FOR PUBLICATION ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANT : ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE : MICHAEL K. AUSBROOK GARY J. CLENDENING DONALD W. FRANCIS, JR. SUZANNAH BEX WILSON Bloomington, Indiana Mallor Clendening Grodner & Bohrer Bloomington, Indiana IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF INDIANA DONALD W. FRANCIS, SR., ) ) Appellant-Defendant, ) ) vs. ) No. 53A01-9801-CV-31 ) HELEN CATHERINE YATES, ) ) Appellee-Plaintiff. ) APPEAL FROM THE MONROE CIRCUIT COURT The Honorable Elizabeth N. Mann, Judge Cause No. 53C04-9703-CP-265 October 21, 1998 OPINION - FOR PUBLICATION RUCKER, Judge In a dispute over the interpretation of a contract the trial court entered summary judgment in favor of property owner Appellee Helen Catherine Yates ("Yates"). Appellant Donald W. Francis, Sr., ("Francis") a potential buyer of the property, now appeals. We address the following rephrased issue: whether the right of first refusal contained in the contract violated the Rule against Perpetuities thus rendering the contract void. We reverse. On January 28, 1988, Francis and Yates entered into a written agreement for the sale and purchase of certain real property. The agreement, which was contained in a document entitled "Offer with Option to Purchase Real Property" provided in part that Francis would purchase three tracts of real estate identified as Tracts A, B, and C, located in Bloomington Township, Monroe County, Indiana. The purchase price for the three tracts was $20,000.00, $20,000.00, and $25,000.00 respectively. Under terms of the agreement Francis also had the option to purchase a fourth tract of real estate known as Tract D. The purchase price for Tract D was $134,900.00, "or as may be hereinafter agreed upon the exercise of the Option by Buyer for Tract D." R. at 20. The details of the option were contained in a section of the agreement entitled "Option with Right of First Refusal to Purchase Real Property Part of Offer and Option to Purchase Real Property" ("Option").

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.