Court of Claims of Illinois April 6, 1998, No. 95-CC-0425 (Keller Construction, Inc. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-04-1998

OPINION

Epstein, J.

In this breach of contract claim against the Department of Transportation (“IDOT”), the Claimant contractor seeks $37,905 in additional compensation for installation of sheet piling that was required for “railroad protection” for the Clark Bridge construction project in Alton, Illinois. This “railroad protection” claim, which arises largely on the standard provisions of IDOT construction contracts, is before us for final decision following trial to our Commissioner, Patrick Hanley. This appears to be the first “railroad protection” construction contract claim to be decided by this Court.

Nature of the Claim

The dispute in this case is over labor and material charges for sheet-piling installation that was required for the protection of railroad traffic and structures adjacent (and under) the bridge construction project that was the subject of Claimants contract with IDOT. This temporary sheet piling for “railroad protection” was not set forth in the contract bid specifications, and was not computed as a cost element of the Claimant’s winning contract bid to IDOT. The piling was required as excavation protection by the railroad’s engineer — after the Claimant’s work had commenced — under the railroad protection provisions of IDOT’s standard specifications, which are incorporated into virtually all IDOT road and bridge construction contracts:

“§105.02 Authority of Railroad Engineer. Whenever the safety of railroad traffic during construction is concerned, the Railroad Engineer will have jurisdiction over safety measures to be taken and his/her decision as to methods, procedure and measures used shall be final, and any and all Contractors performing work near or about the railroad shall be governed by such decision. Instructions to the Contractor by the Railroad Engineer shall be given through the Engineer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.