Spotsylvania County Circuit Court February 20, 1998, Case No. CF97-657, 658, 659 (Commonwealth v. Wills)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-02-1998
By Judge William H. Ledbetter, Jr.
The issue raised by the defendant’s pre-trial motion is whether a “fresh complaint” of a sexual offense is admissible under Virginia Code § 19.2-268.2 even when the victim does not testify.
Facts
The grand jury has indicted Michael John Wills on charges of aggravated sexual battery, sodomy, and felony child abuse. The alleged victim is his three-year-old daughter.
Mr. Wills has been arraigned and has entered pleas of not guilty, and his case is set for trial by jury.
On February 18, 1998, the court heard arguments on Mr. Wills’ pretrial motion to exclude the testimony of Sherry Eskew, the child’s aunt.
Apparently, Mrs. Eskew was the first person to whom the child reported the alleged incident. Consequently, the Commonwealth intends to call Mrs. Eskew as a witness in its case-in-chief so that she can relate the child’s report under the so-called “fresh complaint” or “recent complaint” rule. The Commonwealth concedes that it does not presently intend to call the child as a witness. This circumstance is the basis of Mr. Wills’ motion.
*460
Applicable Law
Hearsay testimony about the original complaint made by a victim of sexual assault is admissible under certain circumstances. The rule, often referred to as the doctrine of “fresh complaint” or “recent complaint,” is usually described as an exception to the hearsay rule. Only the fact of the complaint is admissible; details cannot be given.1 Friend, Law of Evidence in Virginia (4th ed. ¿ 18-29.)
The fresh complaint exception to the hearsay rule is derived from the early English common law rule requiring any victim of violent crime to raise a “hue and cry” so that neighbors would come to his or her aid, engage in a search for the attacker, and dispel any suggestion that the victim concocted the story. The rule was applied with particular force to sexual offenses.
The “hue and cry” rule is now discredited.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit