Fairfax County Circuit Court August 6, 1998, Case No. L 170876 (Roubik v. White)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-1998

By Judge Stanley P. Klein

This cause is before the Court on a demurrer filed by defendants Jack White and State Farm Insurance Co. (collectively “defendants”). Defendants assert that the Motion for Judgment (“MFJ”) filed by plaintiffs Karen and Lauren Roubik is “invalid” because it was drafted and endorsed by Robert Roubik (“Roubik”), a non-lawyer. Karen Roubik and Lauren Roubik are the wife and daughter, respectively, of Robert Roubik. Plaintiffs concede the demurrer should be sustained as to defendant State Farm for reasons unrelated to the issue addressed in this opinion. For the reasons set forth below, the demurrer is sustained and the case is dismissed. Counsel stipulated at oral argument that the validity of the MFJ could be attacked on demurrer. Therefore, the issue of whether a demurrer is the appropriate pleading to contest the legal efficacy of the MFJ under the specific facts of this case need not be decided by the Court.

I. Background

This case arises from an automobile accident which allegedly occurred on April 15, 1996, in the County of Fairfax. According to the allegations contained in the MFJ, plaintiffs were traveling on the Capital Beltway when their vehicle collided with that of defendant White, causing them serious *91injuries. Roubik filed a Motion for Judgment on behalf of plaintiffs in this Court on April 15,1998, exactly two years after the alleged incident. On July 10, 1998, defendants, by “special appearance,” filed their demurrer, and a hearing was held on July 24th. The Court then took the matter under advisement.

II. Analysis

Requirements for pleadings filed in the circuit courts are governed by the Rules of the Virginia Supreme Court. Pursuant to Rule 1:4(c), “[cjounsel1 or an unrepresented party who files a pleading shall sign it and state his address.” Under Rule 1A:4, pleadings or other papers required to be served must be endorsed by a member of the Virginia State Bar, except where a party is representing himself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.