Albemarle County Circuit Court September 28, 1998, Case No. CL98-7407 (Wharton v. Albemarle County School Board)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-09-1998

BY JUDGE PAUL M. PEATROSS, JR.

This matter comes before the Court on Defendant Albemarle County School Board’s Demurrer, which includes as a ground a bar under the doctrine of sovereign immunity. The Court heard argument by counsel on September 14,1998, and took the matter under advisement to consult the authority cited. For the reasons set forth below, the Court finds that: (1) Plaintiffs’ Motion for Judgment states a valid claim against die Albemarle County School Board for negligence; (2) barring a waiver of sovereign immunity under Va. Code § 22.1-194, the School Board is immune from the claim alleged; (3) the legislative intent regarding waiver under Va. Code §§ 22.1-194 and 22.1-190 is sufficiently clear to include the claim alleged, but (4) the issue cannot be decided without considering the language of the insurance policy to determine whether collectible insurance exists. Thus, the Court denies Defendant’s Demurrer but may later sustain a plea of sovereign immunity if analysis of the policy reveals that no collectible insurance exists.

Facts Alleged in the Motion for Judgment

On October 4, 1996, Plaintiff Jude Wharton, a student at Greer Elementary School, was asked to exit from the school bus’ emergency door as part of a school bus evacuation drill. Following the instructions of school employees, Jude bent her knees and jumped from the bus emergency door. It was the job of two older students to assist Jude as she descended to the *170pavement. They did not assist her correctly, and she fell striking her face and stomach on the pavement. As a result of this fall, Jude suffered, among other things, hospitalization with a lacerated liver.

Plaintiff Jude Wharton, by her next Mend and mother, Loran Wharton, brings Count I of the Motion for Judgment against the School Board for negligence in conducting the school bus evacuation drill.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.