Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Crawford County September 14, 1998, no. A.D. 1995-642 (Osborne v. Cambridge Twp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-09-1998

VARDARO, J.,

The matter before this court arises from an action brought under provisions of Pennsylvania’s Wrongful Death and Survival Acts by the plaintiff, Jeanette M. Osborne, in her capacity as administratrix of her husband’s estate. The claims were brought against the defendant, Cambridge Township, as a result of a fatal motor vehicle accident which occurred on a township roadway. It was alleged at trial that the defendant was negligent in its failure to take measures to warn of a large tree which had fallen across one of its roads and for which the township had timely notice of. The decedent was killed instantly when the automobile he was driving struck the fallen tree. The plaintiff’s claims were tried before a jury which returned a verdict in her favor for an aggregate total of $3,892,243.20. Negligence was established at 25 percent for the decedent and 75 percent for the defendant. The defendant has filed motions for judgment n.o.v., new trial, remittitur, and a molding of the verdict. *364The plaintiff has filed a motion to mold verdict, award Rule 238 damages and post-verdict interest. We turn now to address these matters.

DISCUSSION

I. Motion for Judgment n.o.v.

A. Failure To Establish Care, Custody or Control

The defendant asserts that a compulsory nonsuit or a directed verdict should have been granted in favor of the defendant because the evidence set forth at trial failed to establish that the tree which had fallen across the roadway was within the right-of-way of Cambridge Township.

The general immunity of local agencies caused by acts or omissions of the agency or its employees is provided in 42 Pa.C.S. §8541. Exceptions to the general grant of immunity are provided in 42 Pa.C.S. §8542. The specific exception alleged at trial by the plaintiff to establish liability on behalf of the defendant provides the following:

“(4) Tree, traffic controls and street lighting.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.