Court of Appeals of Wisconsin July 30, 1999, 98-3334 (Taylor v. St. Croix Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-07-1999

CANE, C.J.

Duane Taylor appeals from a decision and order granting various defendants' motions

*691

for summary judgment.

1

St. Croix Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin, et. al (St. Croix), Continental Insurance Company (CNA) and Pete Dunkley cross-appeal from a decision and order denying them statutory costs under § 814.03(1), Stats. St. Croix and Dunkley further cross-appeal from the trial court's refusal to grant, or even address, their motion to impose sanctions for frivolous claim pursuant to § 814.025, Stats., and additionally urge this court to impose sanctions against Taylor for a frivolous appeal, pursuant to § 809.25, Stats.

Taylor argues the following: (1) that the St. Croix Chippewa Indians and State of Wisconsin Gaming Compact of 1991 provides a waiver of sovereign immunity allowing a claim against St. Croix for personal injuries where, as here, the personal injuries occurred on a tribal construction site during the building of a tribal youth center, funded by gaming revenues; (2) that CNA's alleged failure to provide waiver language required by the gaming compact and CNA's policy exclusions precluding coverage for Taylor require reformation of CNA's insurance policy; and (3) that the gaming compact's insurance provisions should be construed to label St. Croix a "self-insurer," thereby nullifying St. Croix's sovereign immunity.

We hold that because the gaming compact applies only to gaming activities, Taylor's personal injuries are not covered by any insurance coverage mandated under the compact. As Taylor's injuries are not covered by the compact, there is no need to address reformation

*692

of CNA's insurance policy nor Taylor's contention that St. Croix has expressly waived its sovereign immunity as a "self-insurer" under the compact.

With regard to the various cross-appeals, we hold that the trial court erred by denying statutory costs pursuant to § 814.03, Stats.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.